Charity watchdogs play a crucial role in the U.S. nonprofit sector by providing information, reviews, and ratings for charitable and nonprofit organizations. These watchdogs help donors make informed decisions, ensuring their contributions go to reputable and effective organizations. Despite being grouped under the same umbrella, these watchdogs have distinct missions, operate differently, and can impact your ability to raise necessary funds in various ways.
This article compares four recognized charity watchdogs: Candid (formerly GuideStar), Charity Navigator, BBB Wise Giving Alliance, and GreatNonprofits. We will help your organization understand their purposes and decide whether getting listed with them is worth the effort.
What We’ll Learn
What Is the Purpose of Charity Watchdogs?
Charity watchdogs serve several essential purposes for 501c3 nonprofit organizations and potential donors.
- Transparency and Accountability: They promote transparency by providing detailed information about charities’ operations, finances, and governance.
- Donor Confidence: By rating and reviewing charities, watchdogs help build donor confidence, making it easier for donors to trust that their money will be used effectively.
- Resource Allocation: They assist donors in identifying high-impact organizations, ensuring resources are allocated to charities that can make the most significant difference.
- Encouraging Best Practices: They encourage nonprofits to adopt best practices in governance, financial management, and program implementation.
Who Are the Recognized Charity Watchdogs?
When it comes to charity watchdogs, these four organizations are the most widely recognized and trusted in the nonprofit sector:
- Candid (formerly GuideStar)
- Charity Navigator
- BBB Wise Giving Alliance
- GreatNonprofits
Let’s briefly describe each charity watchdog, examine their key features, and consider their impact on fundraising.
Candid (GuideStar)
Candid was formed in 2019 through the merger of GuideStar and the Foundation Center. It provides comprehensive data on nonprofit organizations, including their financials, operations, and impact. Candid’s database is a valuable resource for donors, funders, researchers, and journalists.
If your organization only has the bandwidth to get listed with one group, getting the Candid Seal of Transparency is likely the most impactful thing you can do for your organization’s reputation.
Key Features of Candid
- Extensive Database: Candid houses information on over 2.7 million nonprofits.
- Nonprofit Profiles: Organizations can update their profiles to provide current information to potential donors.
- Transparency Level Seals: Candid offers four levels of transparency seals (Bronze, Silver, Gold, and Platinum) based on the amount and quality of information provided by a nonprofit.
Candid Fees
There are no fees to get the Candid transparency seals for your organization.
Impact on Fundraising
Being listed as a trusted organization and maintaining an up-to-date profile on Candid can greatly enhance a nonprofit’s visibility and credibility. Donors, including individuals and foundations, use Candid’s database to verify an organization’s legitimacy and effectiveness. Alternatively, not listing a Candid Seal of Transparency can be a red flag for potential donors.
Charity Navigator
Charity Navigator is the next best-known charity watchdog. It provides ratings on U.S. 501c3 organizations based on financial health, accountability, and transparency. Charity Navigator aims to make impactful philanthropy easier for donors by highlighting high-performing charities and charitable categories of organizations.
Charity Navigator automatically lists all nonprofit organizations registered with the IRS, with no action required by the charity. So, try looking up your organization rather than creating a profile.
Key Features of Charity Navigator
- Star Ratings: Charities are rated on a scale from zero to four stars.
- Giving Basket: Charity Navigator allows donors to support organizations on their Giving Basket platform. This feature empowers donors to support multiple charities in one convenient checkout while controlling how much information is shared with organizations.
- Financial Metrics: Charity Navigator evaluates organizations based on financial efficiency, sustainability, and growth. Data is sourced from the IRS, partners, and the charities themselves.
Charity Navigator Fees
There are no fees to get the Charity Navigator star rating, and Charity Navigator does not charge fees to supporters who donate to organizations on its platform.
Impact on Fundraising
A high star rating from Charity Navigator can significantly boost a charity’s reputation, attracting more donors. Conversely, a low rating can deter potential contributors. Therefore, maintaining high standards in financial management and transparency is crucial for a positive rating. Additionally, since donations can be made directly on the Giving Basket platform, this feature offers another revenue stream to organizations.
Better Business Bureau Wise Giving Alliance
The Better Business Bureau Wise Giving Alliance (BBB WGA) evaluates charities against 20 standards for charity accountability, covering governance, results reporting, finances, and fundraising practices. It aims to promote high standards of conduct among nonprofits and educate donors.
Key Features of BBB WGA
- 20 Standards: These standards encompass governance, effectiveness, finance, and appeal accuracy.
- Accreditation: Charities that meet all 20 standards, provide all required information, and complete two fiscal years of operations can receive the BBB Accredited Charity seal. This is a paid service, and charities must pay to be accredited in the program.
- Comprehensive Reports: Detailed reports are available on the BBB WGA website, providing in-depth information on accredited charities.
Wise Giving Alliance Fees
Just like for businesses, the Better Business Bureau charges accreditation fees for nonprofits. Fees are based on a sliding scale, which can go quite high for large organizations. Small nonprofits will pay about $100 – $350 to receive accreditation.
Impact on Fundraising
BBB WGA accreditation signals to donors that a charity adheres to high ethical standards and has been operating for a minimum of two years, which can enhance trust and support. Meeting these standards and paying accreditation fees may require significant effort, but the credibility gained can be invaluable for long-term fundraising success.
GreatNonprofits
GreatNonprofits focuses on community-sourced reviews and ratings, allowing donors, volunteers, and beneficiaries to share their experiences with nonprofits. While this approach may seem less scientific, it aims to provide a personal, authentic perspective on a charity’s impact and operations.
Key Features of GreatNonprofits
- User Reviews: Individuals can leave reviews based on their personal experiences with nonprofits.
- Top-Rated Awards: Charities with a large number of positive reviews can receive a Top-Rated awards badge.
- Community Engagement: Emphasizes feedback from the community to highlight effective and impactful organizations.
GreatNonprofits Fees
There are no fees for organizations to get listed on the GreatNonprofits platform. They simply need to claim their organization and ask supporters to submit reviews.
Impact on Fundraising
Positive reviews on GreatNonprofits can enhance a charity’s reputation and attract more donors and volunteers. While it can be labor-intensive to request reviews and testimonials from your organization’s beneficiaries, engaging with the community can create a supportive network and increase visibility.
Is It Worth It To Get Listed with the 4 Charity Watchdogs?
Getting recognized with charity badges can offer several benefits, but it also requires effort and resources. Here’s a quick breakdown of the pros and cons.
Pros
- Enhanced Credibility: Being listed and rated positively by watchdogs can significantly boost your organization’s credibility, making it easier to attract donors.
- Increased Visibility: Listings on these platforms can increase your nonprofit’s visibility among potential donors, volunteers, and partners.
- Donor Trust: Positive ratings and reviews build trust, reassuring donors that their contributions are in good hands.
- Encouragement to Improve: The standards set by these watchdogs can motivate nonprofits to adopt best practices and improve their operations.
Cons
- Resource Intensive: Maintaining up-to-date profiles, requesting supporter reviews, and meeting the standards set by these watchdogs can be resource intensive. The BBB seal accreditation is a paid program.
- Continuous Monitoring: Organizations need to continuously monitor and update their information to maintain positive ratings and transparency seals.
- Potential Negative Impact: A low rating or negative reviews can harm a nonprofit’s reputation and deter potential donors.
Conclusion on the 4 Major Charity Watchdogs and Their Benefits
Charity watchdogs like Candid, Charity Navigator, BBB Wise Giving Alliance, and GreatNonprofits play a vital role in the nonprofit sector by promoting transparency, accountability, and informed giving. Getting listed and rated by all of these watchdogs can enhance an organization’s credibility and attract donors, and is recommended for these reasons.
By understanding each watchdog’s unique features and requirements, nonprofits can make informed decisions about where to focus their efforts to maximize impact and ensure sustainable growth. If your organization is just starting or has limited resources, we recommend getting listed and maintaining an updated presence on Candid and Charity Navigator.
Proactive engagement with these watchdogs can provide long-term advantages, fostering trust and support from potential donors.
Ready to optimize your nonprofit’s visibility and credibility? Explore DoJiggy today and see how we can help you achieve your fundraising goals.
Related Resources
